Archive for the ‘Strategic Default’ Category

Strategic Default: Thinking About Walking Away-Think Again

Friday, August 13th, 2010

“Strategic default”, has referred to homeowners that can afford their mortgage payments but have come to the conclusion that it is not a sound financial decision to continue to pay on a failed investment. A few years ago, you may not have heard of such a bazaar word, today its a term being discussed in thousands of homes in Arizona, California, Nevada, Florida and others.

The following article is courtesy of Thomson Law PLC Mortgage Mediation Group in Phoenix Arizona.

In the past, a strategic default typically involved abandoning or “walking away” from the home and “jingle mailing” the keys to the lender.  That strategy often later proved very “non-strategic” as it lead to any number of problems such as liability for unpaid HOA dues, property liability issues, incidents of vandalism claims as well as potential deficiency lawsuits filed by the lender.

Since the first wave of these lawsuits have hit those homeowners who exited their properties over the past 2 to 3 years, homeowners are starting to realize that just walking away may not be the best strategy.  To make matters worse, certain homeowners missed their best opportunity to negotiate a settlement and compromise of a second lien through a short sale.  This is a lost opportunity which can later prove to dramatically increase the homeowner’s overall cost and expense to a “walk away”.  Even in those cases where their is no deficiency liability, completing a short sale with a full release from the lender is less derogatory to the credit of the homeowner than is a foreclosure.

When a borrower retains qualified legal counsel, the homeowner’s options and potential liabilities can be accurately assessed and analyzed.  This benefits both the homeowner (to prevent unnecessary commitments to the lender, such as a cash contribution or a note) and the Realtor (who will be better informed of potential problems that could impede the short sale).  Homeowners who are considering a strategic default will typically have more in the way of income and/or assets that are at risk than those homeowners who exit a property due to a financial hardship.  Hence, it is of critical importance to determine the potential deficiency liability risks associated with the loan obligations of those homeowners who are considering a strategic default and to create a strategic exit that allows those homeowners to avoid lawsuits from their lenders while preserving their assets.

We have seen a significant increase in the percentage of clients that are looking for a strategic exit from their properties that are under water.  About a quarter of our clients a year ago fell into this category which is in line with national averages.  Over the past 6 months, however, that percentage has increased significantly.

More and more homeowners are realizing the true extent of the devaluation of their properties and, with the continuing erosion of income in a worsening economy, have reached the inevitable conclusion that they need to exit from their single largest debt obligation. This increase in strategic defaults, however, has not been lost upon the lenders who are increasingly searching for ways by which to seek to impose liability upon these homeowners. More than ever before, homeowners in a strategic default are in need of competent legal counsel to access all options and to provide a strategic exit to their loan obligations through a short sale.

To comment or ask questions on this article or other articles we have written please visit our blog at Blog.MortgageMediationGroup.com.

For more information about Strategic Default or Short Sale please visit www.MortgageMediationGroup.com

Considering a short Sale in Arizona? Contact me for a referral to a competent short sale REALTOR that can help.

For All Your Arizona Marketing, Escrow and Title Needs

Strategic Default-Fannie Mae Increases Penalties

Thursday, June 24th, 2010

Strategic Default

As discussed in previous posts, strategic default is an intentional decision by a borrower to stop making their mortgage payment. What’s interesting with a strategic default is-the borrower can usually afford to make their payment but strategically choose not to because they believe it’s better for their finances. Strategic default usually happens when there is a substantial difference between what is owed on the home and what it’s actually worth, commonly known as being “underwater”.

The process that is Strategic Default is not thought of kindly because of the effect it has and continues to have on our and many other housing markets.

In an effort to stop (or at least get some to think again) Fannie Mae announced policy changes on Wednesday 6/23/10 designed to encourage borrowers to work with their lenders/servicers and explore alternatives to foreclosure. Under these changes, defaulting borrowers who walk away from their homes that had the capacity/ability to pay or did not complete a workout alternative in good faith will be ineligible for a new Fannie Mae-backed mortgage loan for a period of seven years from the day of foreclosure.  In addition, Fannie Mae said it “will take legal action to recoup the outstanding mortgage debt from borrowers who strategically default on their loans in jurisdictions that allow for deficiency judgments.” According to DSNEWS.com, an announcement is expected next month, where the company said it will be instructing its servicers to monitor delinquent loans facing foreclosure and put forth recommendations for cases that warrant the pursuit of deficiency judgments.

“We’re taking these steps to highlight the importance of working with your servicer,” said Terence Edwards, executive vice president for credit portfolio management. “Walking away from a mortgage is bad for borrowers and bad for communities, and our approach is meant to deter the disturbing trend toward strategic defaulting.”

Conversely,  Edwards said borrowers facing hardship who make a good faith effort to resolve their situation with their servicer will preserve the option to be considered for a future Fannie Mae loan in a shorter period of time.

According to Fannie Mae, troubled borrowers who work with their servicers and provide information to help the servicer assess their situation can be considered for foreclosure alternatives, such as a loan modification, a short sale, or a deed-in-lieu of foreclosure. Fannie Mae said borrowers with extenuating circumstances (attempt to lessen the magnitude or seriousness of) who work out one of these options with their servicer could be eligible for a new mortgage loan in three years and in as little as two years depending on the circumstances.

So, what does this mean to anyone “underwater” considering a Strategic Default?  Well, that remains to be seen.  There are arguments that Arizona is an anti-deficiency state-preventing lenders from pursuing a deficiency judgment.

A deficiency judgment is a judgment lien against a debtor, defendant or borrower whose foreclosure sale did not produce sufficient funds to pay the mortgage in full. This option may or may not be available to the lender, depending on whether they have made a recourse or non recourse loan.

So, what should you do?

Although many are considering a strategic default here in Arizona, before executing one you might consider talking to a Real Estate Attorney to discuss your loans and whether deficiency protection applies.  You may find that a short sale would be a better option for you.

As a marketing representative for a national title insurance company, I work with some of the best and brightest Real Estate Attorneys and Realtors in the Phoenix Metro area. Please feel free to contact me for a referral to a local Attorney or short sale Realtor to guide you through the process.

For All Yor Marketing, Escrow and Title Needs

Walking Away-The Reality Of Strategic Default

Sunday, May 9th, 2010

Strategic Default

What would you do?

Strategic Default is essentially walking away from your mortgage “letting your home go” back to the bank, not because you can’t afford the payments but because you don’t want to. In Arizona it is estimated that 50% of the homes are “under water”-they are worth less than the amount owed on them., substantially less, sometimes hundreds of thousands of dollars less. I am a title rep, so I work with lots of industry professionals that have told me stories and I have heard some first hand about the dilemma that goes into the decision to leave or stay. Arizona is one of a handful of states across the U.S. that don’t allow the lender to pursue the homeowners after a foreclosure action, for a deficiency- a fact that may make walking away a clearer decision.

An example of a deficiency would be after a strategic default the lender Forecloses on the mortgage. The unpaid balance of the loan is $300,000. The property is sold at public Auction and brings $200,000. The lender then seeks a deficiency judgment against the mortgagor to recover the $100,000 shortage, plus any foreclosure expenses. This is generally not possible here in Arizona. ***

The decision-On one hand there is the obligation that was made. “Dear Mr. Banker, Yes…I promise to repay this loan” On the other there is the business decision. “Do I really want to keep making a payment on a home that is worth less that half of what I paid?

And that brings up an interesting point-I have heard of a “shadow inventory” for well over 2 years, this mass amount of foreclosures that will be hitting the market any day now. If its true, -and I like many others have no clue if it is-, I want it to hit so we can begin the road to recovery!  We know exactly how many trustee sales there are taking place so we can estimate how many will turn into REO’s or Real Estate Owned-The inventory of REO’s in Phoenix has been declining sharply I might add. The one thing that no one can possibly forsee or prepare for is the number of strategic defaults and how that will effect our housing market. Across the United States there are approximately 11 Million homeowners that are “under water”, according to the report below from 60 Minutes, that number could double in the next year.

Walking away essentially perpetuates the decline of value in a neighborhood as it brings down the value of the rest of the homes in the subdivision, therefor everyone is effected.

I learned some interesting facts from watching 60 Minutes tonight about Strategic Default and the numbers are bigger than I could have imagined.


Watch CBS News Videos Online

According to this report, Citibank estimates that 1 in 5 or 20% of borrowers that default on their mortgages are able to pay. a number that could certainly rise.  If this is indeed the case, doesn’t it make sense for the lenders to attempt some form of principle reduction?  Wouldn’t they lose less money by reducing the amount owed than foreclosing?

So what would you do?

*** Be sure to consult with a real estate attorney and/or CPA to see how a foreclosure will effect you.

For All Your Marketing, Escrow and Title Needs

Strategic Default-The New Reality-Updated

Saturday, March 6th, 2010

Strategic Default is a buzz word this year. In case you live under a rock and have not heard of the term before, in a nutshell, strategic default is when someone intentionally “walks away” from their home, even though they could afford to make the mortgage payment.

There are 2 sides to every debate and this one is no different.

There are those that believe they made a commitment, gave their word and they should live up to their obligation. Period.

Then there are those that see strategic default as a business decision. They see walking away from their home as more financially advantageous than continuing to make the mortgage payment.

Now……I have my own opinion regarding strategic default, one that I won’t share here. I did however come across an excellent video titled “Three Steps To Plan for Strategic Default”.

Once again, I don’t necessarily support either side, but this is great information to consider.

If you are a homeowner in the Phoenix Metro area and are considering walking away from your home, you may find short sale to be a better option.  Please call or email me for a confidential referral to a Certified Distressed Property Expert (CDPE) Realtor that can better explain your options.

For All Your Marketing, Escrow and Title Needs

Contact Me

Stephen Garner
Phone: 480-223-8113
Fax: 480-892-2680